Recommended partner · Cakes and desserts

Cindy’s Cakery

Romantic buttercream wedding cakes with effortless sophistication, delivered across the Peninsula and Middle Peninsula.

Why we recommend them

A reflection of the two of you

Cindy believes a wedding cake is much more than a dessert. Her style blends timeless elegance with classic flavors, and she approaches every cake with the same care as if it were for her own loved ones.

Services

From tasting to delivery

  • Custom buttercream wedding cakes, with cupcakes as an option
  • Tasting consultations by appointment, with a sampler box
  • Custom handmade sugar flowers, or placement of fresh florals from your florist
  • Cake stand, plateau and cupcake tower rentals

Working together

Weddings we have shared

We have worked alongside Cindy's Cakery at Peninsula weddings. We cue the cake cutting with the photographer and catering team so it lands at the right moment. We coordinate timelines, microphones and big moments with every partner before the day, so hand-offs stay smooth.

At a glance

Quick facts

  • Price range$$Moderate compared with similar wedding bakeries
  • Based inGloucesterBy-appointment studio
  • DeliveryWilliamsburg and beyondYorktown, Newport News, Mathews and the Northern Neck
  • Lead time4+ weeksNo last-minute requests

Price ranges are our relative estimates compared with similar vendors in Virginia: $ budget-friendly, $$ moderate, $$$ upscale, $$$$ luxury. Ask the vendor directly for a current quote.

Common questions

Good questions to ask

Is the kitchen allergen-free?
No. Wheat, nuts, eggs and dairy are used regularly. Some special requests, such as gluten-friendly cakes, may be possible depending on allergy severity.

Contact

Reach Cindy's Cakery directly

Websitecindyscakery.com

LocationGloucester, delivering to Williamsburg, Yorktown, Newport News, Charles City, Mathews and the Northern Neck

Cindy's Cakery is an independent business and is not part of The Signature Entertainment Group. Details on this page come from their published information as of November 2026. Please confirm pricing, hours and availability directly with them.

Planning your wedding entertainment?

Tell us who is on your vendor team. We coordinate timelines, sound and big moments with every partner on the day.